Senior Pastor - Shawn Otto 9413719647 Shawn became the Senior Pastor of Bethel Mennonite Church in April 2014 after serving nine years in pastoral ministry in Indiana.  Shawn is a member of the Association of Certified Biblical Counselors and holds a Master of Arts degree in Biblical Counseling from Faith Bible Seminary in Lafayette, Indiana.   He and his wife, Greta, are the parents of two daughters and two sons.

Associate/Youth Pastor/Children's Coord. Interim - Ryan Mayer 9413760717 Ryan was commissioned as Youth Pastor February 28, 2010.  He began serving as Associate Pastor half time in September 2013.  Ryan graduated in 2009 from Clearwater Christian College and was serving as a youth sponsor at Bay Shore Mennonite Church before coming to Bethel.  He and his wife, Carrie, are the parents of two daughters and one son.

Pastor of Care - Jason Beiler 9419578914 Jason began serving as Pastor of Care of Bethel Mennonite Church in August, 2017.  He has a degree in Business Administration from University of South Florida.  In the last 2 years, he has worked as a Director of Visitation for a number of churches in Jacksonville, visiting seniors in homes or retirement centers.  He and his wife, Debby, have two daughters.

Head Elder - AJ Miller

Elder - Sheldon Campbell

Elder - Scott Kauffman

Elder - Jason Mast

Elder - Scott Miller

Elder - Mahlon Strader

Deacon Chairman - Jon Yutzy

Budget Deacon - Benji Kauffman

Missions Deacon - Jeff Mast

Facilities Deacon - Jim Schmucker

Office Administrator - Kris Troyer 941-371-9647 Office Hours: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM - Monday thru Thursday   Kris began her position as Office Administrator on October 21, 2019.  She and her husband, Omar are the parents of 2 sons and 1 daughter.  She has attended Bethel for 30+ years and has served in various areas within the church over the years.